Have We Overcomplicated Fitness?

Twenty-five years ago, somebody decided they wanted to start lifting.

Maybe a friend showed them some exercises. Maybe they bought a book or magazine. Maybe they found a simple program somebody at the gym had been using for years.

Was it scientifically optimized?

Probably not.

Did they know their optimal training frequency, RIR, RPE, weekly volume, protein timing, mesocycle, deload strategy, and whether incline dumbbell press produces slightly greater upper-pec activation than whatever some guy on YouTube did yesterday?

Nope.

They lifted weights.

Today, before somebody performs their first squat, we can give them 600 opinions about how they should squat.

Knowledge is enormously valuable. We know far more about strength training, nutrition, recovery, and exercise science than we did a generation ago, and much of that information is available to anyone with a phone.

But there's a point where more information stops creating confidence and starts creating uncertainty.

For someone trying to start, or trying to get back into the gym after being away for a while, that can be a problem.

When More Information Creates Less Confidence

Think about the all the questions someone can encounter before completing their first week of training.

Should I train three days a week or five? Full body or push-pull-legs? Machines or free weights? Heavy weight or moderate weight? Three sets or four? Six reps or twelve? Should I train to failure? How long should I rest? Should I do cardio before lifting or afterward? Should I take creatine? Do I need a deload week?

Those are legitimate questions, and there are legitimate reasons to discuss every one of them.

The problem is that someone who hasn't started training yet doesn't necessarily need definitive answers to all of them.

They only need somewhere reasonable to begin.

That's where the enormous amount of fitness information available today creates an interesting contradiction. We have more information than ever about how to exercise, yet all of that information leaves someone less certain about what they should actually do.

One expert recommends one approach and another recommends something different. Someone on social media insists they're both wrong. Then there is an algorithm that delivers twelve more opinions all because you watched the first three.

Eventually, researching your workout replaces actually doing one.

You Don't Have to Solve Fitness Before You're Allowed to Participate in It

There is an important distinction between making a good decision and making the perfect decision.

If you're beginning strength training, you don't need the perfect workout. You need a reasonable workout that you can perform safely, understand, repeat, and that will help you to gradually improve.

Choose a sensible program. Learn the exercises. Start with manageable weights. Give yourself enough time to become familiar with what you're doing. There will be opportunities to refine everything later.

That's part of the thinking behind eFitLog. We include ready-to-use Beginner, Intermediate, and Core workouts because sometimes the most useful thing a fitness application can do isn't give you another hundred decisions to make. It's give you a reasonable place to begin.

You can use those workouts, change them as you learn, or eventually build your own. The goal isn't to tell you that there is one perfect way to train. It's to remove enough uncertainty that you actually start training.

Because something important happens once you do. You begin accumulating your own experience. And eventually, your own data enters the conversation.

When Your Own Data Enters the Conversation

This is where fitness becomes considerably more interesting.

Before you begin training, almost every question you have must be answered using someone else's experience, research, recommendations, or opinions. That's necessary since we all have to start somewhere. But after you've trained consistently for a while, you begin accumulating information about yourself.

Instead of asking, "How many sets should people perform?" you can begin asking, "How am I responding to three?"

Instead of asking, "What's the perfect workout frequency?" you can ask, "Can I consistently train four days a week and still completely recover from it or is it too much?"

Instead of asking, "How much should I bench?" you know what you benched last week. That informs what you may want to bench the next time, and so on.

Now the discussion changes.

You know how many repetitions you completed. You know what weight you used. You know whether you improved. You know which exercises you've been performing consistently and which ones you haven't. Over enough time, you begin seeing patterns that no article, video, influencer, or fitness calculator could have shown you before you started.

They're your patterns.

This is one of the reasons eFitLog puts previous workout information where you're actually logging the next one. No one wants to stop in the middle of a workout, dig through menus, and search through months of history just to answer a simple question:

What did I do last time?

Your previous performance, historical information, and the workout you're performing now belong in the same conversation because all that information helps you make the next decision.

That's when a workout log stops being merely a record of what happened. It starts becoming useful information about what should happen next.

A Workout Log Tells You What You Did. A Training History Helps Explains What Is Happening.

There is a reason people have kept training logs for generations. And although the technology has changed the underlying idea hasn't. Track what you've done so you can better manage what to do next.

If you record what you do, you can compare today's performance with yesterday's. String enough of those workouts together and you can begin comparing weeks, months, exercises, weights, repetitions, personal records, and trends.

You no longer have to rely entirely on how you feel about your progress.

You can look.

That's also why eFitLog doesn't treat logging the workout as the end of the process. Workout statistics, lift history, exercise trends, personal records, measurements, cardio history, and other progress tools exist to help turn all those individual workouts into something you can actually learn from.

A single workout tells you something.

Fifty workouts tell you considerably more.

The same applies to cardio. One run gives you a time and distance. Repeated sessions begin giving you pace comparisons, splits, heart-rate information, fastest miles, distance trends, and a history you can compare.

None of that means the numbers should control your training. Not everything that matters can be reduced to a chart. But the numbers can replace some uncertainty with evidence.

And evidence has a wonderful habit of building confidence.

That's When Fitness Starts Becoming Yours

Something changes after you've trained long enough. You stop needing an answer to every question before you act.

You still learn. You still read. You still listen to people who know more than you do. Good information remains valuable no matter how experienced you become. But now you have something to compare that information against.

Your experience.

Someone can tell you that a particular training split is optimal, but you know whether it fits your life.

Someone can recommend a certain exercise, but you know whether you enjoy performing it, whether you can perform it comfortably, and whether you've progressed using it.

Someone can tell you exactly how many days you should train, but eventually you learn how many days you can realistically train consistently.

That distinction matters because fitness doesn't happen in a laboratory. It happens while people are working jobs, raising children, taking vacations, getting sick, dealing with unexpected obligations, sleeping badly occasionally, missing workouts, and generally living their lives.

The best program in the world isn't very useful if you can't actually follow it.

The Perfect Workout Is a Moving Target Anyway

Even if someone handed you the perfect workout today, there's another problem. You won't be the same person forever.

You become stronger. Your conditioning improves. Your goals change. Your schedule changes. Exercises that once challenged you become easier. You discover movements you enjoy and others you don't. Sometimes life gives you more time to train, and sometimes it gives you less.

Training has to adapt because you adapt.

That is one reason planning is useful without becoming rigid.

The planning side of eFitLog was built around that idea. You can create workouts and routines and schedule your training ahead, but the plan isn't carved into stone. Miss a workout and you can reschedule it. Change your routine and build another. Plan thirty, sixty, or ninety days ahead if that structure helps you, or simply start a workout when you're ready.

A useful training plan should provide direction without pretending that life will always cooperate with it. There is a tremendous amount of difference between having a plan and being imprisoned by one.

The plan gives you somewhere to go.

Your results help you decide whether you should keep going there.

Maybe Confidence Doesn't Come From Knowing Everything

This is the part we sometimes get backwards. We assume confidence comes first.

We think we need to know exactly what we're doing before we walk into the gym, start the program, pick up the weights, or begin again after months—or years—away. And in a perfect world, we absolutely would.

But confidence builds in the opposite direction. You start without knowing everything.

You complete a workout.

Then another.

You begin recognizing the exercises. You remember what weight you used. You add a few repetitions. Eventually you add some weight. Something that felt awkward becomes familiar.

One day you look back and realize you're no longer wondering whether you belong there.

You're already there.

The uncertainty didn't disappear because somebody finally gave you the perfect answer. It disappeared because experience replaced it.

Technology Should Reduce Uncertainty, Not Add to It

There is an irony in building fitness software.

An app designed to make training easier can become another source of complexity.

More screens. More menus. More metrics. More decisions. More notifications. More things demanding your attention while you're trying to exercise.

That's not particularly helpful.

Technology should earn its place in your workout.

It should remember things you shouldn't have to remember. It should organize information you shouldn't have to organize manually. It should make useful information easier to find. It should help you see progress that's difficult to see from one workout to the next.

And then, ideally, it should get out of the way so you can train.

That's ultimately what we're trying to build with eFitLog.

Not an app that claims to have discovered the perfect workout, and certainly not another source of 600 opinions about how you should squat.

We want to provide the structure to help you begin, the tools to help you train, and the history and insights that help you understand your own progress.

Because the more you understand what you are doing and how you are responding, the less you have to guess.

You Can Figure Out the Rest Along the Way

Twenty-five years ago, plenty of people started exercising without knowing what RPE meant.

Somehow, they survived.

Today we have access to extraordinary information, better tools, better research, wearable technology, detailed training histories, and insights previous generations of recreational lifters could only have imagined.

We should use them.

But we shouldn't allow all that information to convince someone that fitness has become too complicated for them to begin.

There will always be another study to read, another program to consider, another exercise to try, and another person on the Internet willing to tell you that you're doing everything wrong.

Keep learning. Ask questions. Seek good information. Change things when there is a reason to change them.

But don't confuse learning about fitness with actually becoming fit.

At some point, you have to choose something reasonable and begin.

You can figure out the rest along the way.

Find the confidence to start. We'll help you build the confidence to succeed.

That is the eFitLog promise.

← Back to Blog